The Question
Supermarket own-brand condiments keep getting better. So what happens to the artisan producers who have been making preserves since 1970? Can heritage and craftsmanship still justify charging two or three times the price? I asked 10 UK consumers.
So I ran a study. I recruited 10 UK consumers aged 30-60. Regular condiment buyers, a mix of budget-conscious and quality-seeking shoppers from across Britain. 7 questions, no script, no leading. Just honest reactions.
The Participants
10 consumers aged 32-60 from Leeds, Kirklees, Bradford, Manchester and beyond. A proper cross-section of everyday shoppers.
Supermarket own-brand condiments keep getting better. What would a pre...
This one got people talking.
Short answer: almost never.
— Craig Hargreaves
Honest? Nothing for my weekly shop.
— Daniel Rhodes
Two or three times the price is a big ask.
— Caroline Hargreaves
Key insight: The consistency across responses is striking. This is not a fringe opinion.
How do you discover new condiment brands? Do you experiment or stick w...
This one got people talking.
Mostly I stick with what I know.
— Helen Carter-Sharma
Gut feel? I stick with what I know.
— Daniel Rhodes
Short answer: I mostly stick with what I know.
— Caroline Hargreaves
Key insight: The consistency across responses is striking. This is not a fringe opinion.
Would you buy a jar of artisan chutney or mustard as a gift? For whom ...
This one got people talking.
I’m not handing over silly money for a jar with twine.
— Deirdre McKenna
I don’t buy jars as gifts most times.
— Tunde Adeyemi
Yeah, but only now and then.
— Daniel Rhodes
Key insight: The consistency across responses is striking. This is not a fringe opinion.
If a condiment brand told you they have been making preserves the same...
What This Means for Brands
The findings paint a clear picture. Here is what brands in this category should take away:
Own-brand is perceived as good enough. Justifying 2-3x pricing is extremely difficult.
Heritage (since 1970) is a tiebreaker, not a purchase driver. Proof on the spoon wins.
Gifting is the premium sweet spot, but almost exclusively at Christmas for cheese-mad relatives.
Consumers do not experiment with condiments. Trial requires low-risk in-store discovery.
The Bigger Picture
The premium condiment market faces a fundamental challenge: consumers believe own-brand is good enough. Heritage and artisan credentials are nice, but they do not open wallets. The brands that win will be the ones that prove the difference on the spoon, price trial packs affordably, and own the gifting occasion.
Want to test your own positioning? FishDog lets you run studies like this in minutes. Book a demo at fish.dog.
What the Research Revealed
We asked real consumers to share their thoughts. Here is what they told us:
Supermarket own-brand condiments keep getting better. What would a premium brand need to offer to justify being two or three times the price of own-brand?
Craig Hargreaves, 42, Unemployed Adult, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Short answer: almost never. Own-brand is solid now. If you want me paying 2-3x, it has to earn it after a taste, not a story. What would justify it for me: Taste that slaps on a tiny spoon - proper depth, not sticky-sweet. I want heat or tang that actually lifts a cheese toastieHigh stuff content - more fruit or mustard seed, less sugar. I don’t want gloopy syrupDecent jar size or it lasts longer - 280-300g and doesn’t go watery or crustyVersatile - good on cheese, roast, BBQ, sarnies. Say it on the label and give a quick serving ideaSimple ingredients I recognise. Clear allergy info. No weird gumsReal maker I can point to - local or at least not a fake farm name. Happy to pay a bit if it feels honestProof - taste on the stall, or a no-quibble money-back. Reviews on the shelf helpPractica
Daniel Rhodes, 32, Youth Apprentice, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Honest? Nothing for my weekly shop. Own-brand is decent now. Two or three times the price? Sigh. Nah. Maybe for a gift at Christmas. Not for our cupboard. If you want me to pay it, you need: Taste that wows - proper kick, not sweet sludge Stronger - I use half as much, jar lasts 2x Bigger jar or bundle - unit price close to my usual Squeezy that shuts - no leaks, no crust, less waste Lower sugar but still tastes right Try-before and a money-back if it’s naff Clear uses - cheese, cold meats, cooking, all good Promo - under £3 or 2 for a fiver at least Week to week though? No. Price per 100g rules. If it’s silly money, it stays on the shelf.
Caroline Hargreaves, 60, Registered Nurse, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short answer: no. Two or three times the price is a big ask. Own-brand is good now. A premium jar would have to earn it on the spoon, not the label. What would actually justify it for me: Clear win in a blind spoon test - richer fruit or veg upfront, balanced acid, proper heat, no sugary vinegar smack, no gloopy thickenersPerformance in use - holds texture in a pan, caramelises for a glaze, cuts through fatty meats, punches up a cheese board, not just sandwich fillerIngredients that explain the cost - higher real produce content, whole spices, real mustard bite, less sugar, no cheap syrupsProvenance with substance - named UK crop or season I recognise, batch/date, maker contact, not “small batch” fluffRight format - sensible jar size for one person, wide mouth, clean pour, tamper seal, fu
Sophie Hargreaves, 32, Office Manager, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short answer: nothing for the weekly shop. Two or three times the price is a no when own-brand is already solid. If a jar’s £4-£6, it has to graft hard or it’ll just sulk at the back of the fridge. What would make me even think twice: Taste that smacks you - proper depth or heat you can’t fake. Blind, I should spot it. Cleaner recipe - fruit first in chutney, less sugar, no weird gloop. You can taste the real stuff. Versatile - works with cheddar, cold meats, a pork pie, and I can whisk it into a dressing. Not a one-trick jar. Size and shelf life - decent jar, long date, stays good after opening. I want value per 100g, not a cute thimble. No-faff packaging - wide neck, lid that doesn’t crust up. For ketchup, a squeeze that doesn’t splutter. Proven rave - mates bang on about it, or a Which
Tunde Adeyemi, 45, Call Center Representative, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Short answer, it rarely does. Own-brand is solid now, so 2x or 3x needs to be special, not vibes. For that money, I’d want: Taste that slaps on a blind try. Less sugar, clean heat, real depth.Real stuff inside - chunky fruit, whole seeds, proper peppers. Not watery.Same punch every jar. No random heat swings.Normal or bigger jar, not a tiny 100g. Clear date. Keeps well.Short list of things I know. No weird oil or gum.Try-before-you-buy or a small tester in the box.Money-back, no faff if it’s mid.Use guide on the label - wings, plantain, jollof - and it actually works.Decent deal sometimes - Clubcard drop or 2-for offer. If it’s £3.50 for the same as the £1.20 jar, I walk past. I’m not paying for a cute label and a story. Just need to know the total, yeah?
Alison Greaves, 56, Quality Assurance Engineer, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Short answer: they can’t, not for everyday. Own-brand is good now. To pull 2-3x from me, it has to smash a blind spoon test and back it up on the label. No twine, no fairy tale. What would earn it: Obvious flavour win - side by side, it’s brighter, cleaner, proper heat or high fruit. Not just sweeter. Clean build - short ingredient list, real fruit or whole mustard seed, no gloopy thickeners. Sugar lower per 100g than the cheap one. Proof on pack - batch/date, clear allergens, where key stuff came from. Not “crafted in small batches” vagueness. Decent jar and format - 200-250g, wide mouth, doesn’t crust, keeps its texture after opening. Stack in a cupboard, not a prop. Consistency - same heat and texture every time. No watery top, no syrupy sludge. Try-before-you-buy or a straight guaran
Kelly Atkinson, 47, Customer Success Manager, Bradford, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short answer - almost nothing. Own-brand is solid now, so two or three times the price needs to earn its keep or it can jog on. Week in, week out, I’m not paying it. Maybe for a one-off cheese night or Christmas if it clearly beats the basics. What it would need, no faff: Taste that slaps in a blind bite. Big flavour, clean finish, not syrupy. Short, honest ingredients. Real fruit or spice, no weird thickeners, less sugar. More in the jar or more punch per spoon. Either bigger weight or so concentrated I use half as much. Clear provenance I can verify. Named place, batch date, not pretend rustic with twine. Sample or money-back promise if it’s not a wow. Put your jar where your mouth is. Accurate heat level and a quick pairing note that’s actually useful. No shrinkflation tricks. Straight
Helen Carter-Sharma, 56, Carpenter, Manchester, Greater Manchester, United Kingdom:
Short answer - nearly nothing. Own-brand is solid these days, so charging two or three times more has to feel like a different food, not the same sweet gloop in a fancy jar. If you want me to bite, it needs to hit all these at once, not one or two. Knockout taste I can smell as soon as I crack it. Fresh roasted spice, clean heat, no claggy thickeners. Proper texture - real bits of fruit or veg, not jelly. A teaspoon should change a whole pan of dal or lift cheese on toast. Simple ingredients I’d use at home, with less sugar and vinegar. Nothing I can’t pronounce. Freshness and truth - batch date written by hand, maker I can talk to, and I can taste it at the stall. No twine, no wax, no faff. Jar that earns its keep - standard lid, wide mouth, good glass. Refill or return scheme at Levy or
Conor Keane, 42, Data Analyst, Kirklees, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short answer: almost nothing. At two or three times the price it has to be a different beast, not the same gloop in a twee jar. If I’m even thinking about it, I want all of this: Blind-test flavour jump - on a cheese toastie or a pork pie it should smack harder straight away, not just a bit nicer Real ingredients up top - 60%+ fruit in chutney or loads of whole mustard seed, proper malt or cider vinegar, toasted spices, no cheap syrups or thickeners Texture and cook performance - chunky fruit or proper grind, it clings and caramelises in a pan, doesn’t weep or turn to vinegary soup when heated Unique profile I can’t get cheap - fresh horseradish that clears the head, real smoke not flavouring, a fermented chilli that’s deep not just hot, seasonal combos that actually make sense Provenance
Deirdre McKenna, 52, Home Health Aide, Belfast, Belfast, United Kingdom:
Honestly? Two or three times the price - near never. Own-brand is grand now. If you want me to pay silly money, it has to knock my socks off, not just sit pretty with a bit of twine. Most days I’ll put the kettle on, look at the label, and walk on. The only way I’d even think about 2-3x: Taste I can tell blind - thicker, proper fruit or spice, not just sharp vinegar. Big flavour so I use less. Proof on the tongue - a wee sample, or a no-quibble money-back if it’s not lovely. And a phone number I can actually ring. Keeps well - no watery layer, no rusty lid, stays tasty a month after opening. Simple stuff inside I know - not loads of sugar and add-ins. Real mustard kick, not sweet yellow paste. Does more than one job - good with cheese, lifts a ham sandwich, and perks up chicken. Not a on
How do you discover new condiment brands? Do you experiment or stick with what you know? What would make you try something unfamiliar?
Helen Carter-Sharma, 56, Carpenter, Manchester, Greater Manchester, United Kingdom:
Mostly I stick with what I know. I spot new ones at Levy market, the Curry Mile grocers, temple fairs, or when a neighbour shoves a cracker in my hand and says “try this.” I don’t chase brands and I don’t buy off a fancy shelf card - that’s daft. If I can smell it and taste it there and then, and the price is sensible, I’ll think about it. What makes me try something unfamiliar: A proper taste on a clean spoon so I know it’s not sweet gloop.Simple ingredients I can read, veggie marked, heat level clear.Sensible price or small jar - £2–3 or a mini, not a £5 punt.Trust - maker at the stall, auntie on the Curry Mile, or a neighbour who swears by it.Handwritten batch date and a decent reusable jar.Works with more than one thing - lifts dal and a cheese butty, not a one-trick pony. If it ticks
Daniel Rhodes, 32, Youth Apprentice, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Gut feel? I stick with what I know. Busy week, tight cash. If I gamble and it’s naff, that’s money binned. Sigh. How I find new stuff: Supermarket offer that beats my usual on unit price Mate’s BBQ and it tastes proper Free sample at a market or school fair Yellow sticker on a jar I’d never pay full for Free sachet in a takeaway that’s got a kick New line in Aldi/Lidl with an intro price What makes me try it: Under £2.50 for jars like chutney or mustard Big intro deal or 2 for a fiver Taste test that’s thick and strong, not sweet sludge Bigger jar for same money, or stronger so it lasts Squeezy bottle and a cap that shuts Clear heat level, plain flavour names Yorkshire helps as a tie-breaker if the taste is ace Fancy story and rustic twine? Nah. Show me price per 100g and let me tas
Caroline Hargreaves, 60, Registered Nurse, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short answer: I mostly stick with what I know. I don’t go hunting for condiments. They’re slow-use items, so a dud jar just clutters the fridge and annoys me. How I actually find new ones: Kirkgate Market - if I can taste it on the stall, I’ll consider itLocal deli or farm shop on a UK break - sample on the counter, clear origin on the labelCheese counter recommendations when I’m building a board for IanWord of mouth - Maureen or a sensible friend, not influencers or InstagramOccasionally a mention in the Times or Radio 4 makes me note it, but I still want a taste What gets me to try something unfamiliar: Taste first - a sample or a mini jarClean label - short ingredients, proper spice, no gloopy thickenersClear origin I recognise - damson, rhubarb, or a named place, not vague “small bat
Conor Keane, 42, Data Analyst, Kirklees, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short version - I mostly stick with what I know. I’ll try something new if I stumble on it and it doesn’t take the mick on price. I’m not trawling Instagram for relish ideas, like. Where I find new ones: - A Saturday market in town where you can have a nibble on a cracker - A mate’s BBQ or a neighbour’s cheese board where it actually lifts the bite - Supermarket seasonal aisle or the reduced shelf if it’s a sensible punt - The local butcher with tasters out - Now and then a YouTube BBQ bloke mentions a style and I’ll keep an eye out, but I’m not chasing it round three shops What gets me to try something unfamiliar: Free taste first - if it smacks of real spice or fruit, not just vinegarIntro offer or fair price per 100g - around 50p to a quid over own-brand, not doubleShort ingredients w
Kelly Atkinson, 47, Customer Success Manager, Bradford, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Mostly I stick with my regulars. I’ll try new stuff if there’s a clear reason, not for a cute label. Time’s short and my fridge door isn’t a museum. How I find new ones: Local markets round Saltaire or a farm shop - if I can taste it, I’ll listen. Mates bring something to a cheese night or BBQ and it’s a hit. Supermarket end-aisle when it’s on offer or a trial size. Honest posts in local Facebook groups - real people, not influencers. A quick TikTok or Insta recipe where the sauce actually looks decent. What gets me to try: Taste first - a sample or a mate saying it’s cracking. Price that’s close to my usual - I’ll stretch 50p-£1 if it earns it. Short, straight ingredients and not loaded with sugar. Clear heat level and a simple pairing note - tell me it’s good with cheddar or cold ham.
Tunde Adeyemi, 45, Call Center Representative, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Mostly I stick with what I know. Own-brand ketchup and mustard are sorted. I’ll mess about with hot sauce a bit, but not loads. I spot new stuff on Tesco end caps with Clubcard tags, Aldi specials, and the shops on Soho Road. Street food spots or Digbeth, if the maker has a stall and I can taste it. Sometimes a mate brings a bottle to a BBQ and I clock it. Instagram ads, I scroll past. I’ll try something new if: Price drops under £2 or it’s on Clubcard price.I can taste a sample at a stall.There’s a small bottle to test, not a massive jar.A mate swears it bangs with wings or burgers.Label is clear and short. Not loads of sugar.Heat level shown, like 1-5, so I know the kick.It says what it goes with - chicken, plantain, jollof. If it’s £4 for a tiny jar, forget it. Just need to know the tot
Alison Greaves, 56, Quality Assurance Engineer, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Short answer: I stick with what works. I’m not trawling the condiment aisle for sport. I’ll try something new if there’s proof it’s better, not just a story. How I actually find new ones: Markets - Kings Heath or Moseley. If there’s a taster and a straight chat with the maker, I’ll listen. At a mate’s house - if Julie plonks a mustard on the table and it’s got proper heat, I’ll note it. Supermarket promos - intro price or yellow sticker on something that looks sensible. I’ll grab one jar to test. Farm shops on a walk - usually pricey. If there’s a sample and it’s clearly better, maybe one jar, not a hamper. Decent reviews - a proper taste test with specifics, not fluff. If people say “good nose-clearing heat” or “high fruit, not syrupy,” I’ll bite. What makes me try something unfamilia
Craig Hargreaves, 42, Unemployed Adult, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Mostly I stick with what I know. Own-brand mustard, brown sauce, ketchup, mango chutney. I’ll try new stuff now and then, but only if it’s low risk and not silly money. How I find new ones: Local markets round Kings Heath or Moseley if there’s a taste on the stallSupermarket offers on the end aisle or Clubcard price that puts it near own-brandGifts at Christmas or a host gift someone brings - if it’s decent, I might rebuyMates at a BBQ who say “try this” and it actually slapsFarm shops on UK breaks if there’s a sample and it’s not a tourist tax What makes me try something unfamiliar: Taste first - tiny spoon, no wafflePrice in the right ballpark - 50p more than own-brand, maybe £1 if it’s crackingClear use on the label - good with cheese, roast, sarnies, leftoversSimple ingredients I rec
Sophie Hargreaves, 32, Office Manager, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short answer: I mostly stick with what I know. I’m not wandering round hunting “artisan” jars. For ketchup and mayo we buy the usual because Isla notices. I’ll only dabble with chutney or mustard if the price and taste make sense. Where I actually find new ones: Free tasters at markets - Kirkstall Deli Market, the odd farm shop on a Dales day out. If I can taste it, I might bite. Supermarket promos - end-of-aisle with a sensible intro price. If it’s near the own-brand on price, I’ll try one. Friends’ tables - cheese night, BBQ, Sunday roast. If it bangs with pork pie, I’ll ask where it’s from. Gift hampers at Christmas - if a jar’s decent in there, I’ll remember it. Mumsnet threads/Which? taste tests - if everyone says it’s miles better, I’ll give it a go once. What would make me try som
Would you buy a jar of artisan chutney or mustard as a gift? For whom and on what occasion? What makes a condiment feel gift-worthy?
Deirdre McKenna, 52, Home Health Aide, Belfast, Belfast, United Kingdom:
Mostly no. I’m not handing over silly money for a jar with twine. I’ll buy a fancy chutney as a wee add-in if it truly suits the person and the moment. I’ll put the kettle on and think, do they even like chutney... or will it sit in a cupboard till next Christmas? Who I’d buy for Mum in Donegal - Christmas hamper with cheese, oatcakes, and a proper chutney. A neighbour as a thank-you for feeding the cat - a small jar with a loaf or crackers. A foodie friend who does boards - housewarming or a wee host gift. Work Secret Santa if they’re mad for cheese. Otherwise, no point. What makes it feel gift-worthy Taste I’ve tried at a local stall. Thick, not watery. You can see the fruit or the grain. Real kick for mustard, not just yellow and sweet. Simple ingredients I know. Not daft combos fo
Tunde Adeyemi, 45, Call Center Representative, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Short answer, not really. I don’t buy jars as gifts most times. I’d do it at Christmas for Sade’s aunt or my uncle who loves a cheese board. Maybe a Secret Santa at work with a tenner cap. House-warming if they’re proper into food. Not for my mates - they’d laugh and leave it in the cupboard. What makes it feel gift-worthy: Thick and chunky, strong kick. Not just sugar.Heavy glass, clean lid, clear date.Short list on the label. Stuff I know.Looks tidy in a set with crackers or a small cheese. Price-wise I cap it at £4 a jar, or £10 if I build a small hamper. Just need to know the total, yeah?
Daniel Rhodes, 32, Youth Apprentice, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Yeah, but only now and then. Christmas mainly. For mum or my father-in-law who loves a cheese board. Under £3 a jar or 2 for a fiver. Over that, nah. Maybe a small thank you for a neighbour if it’s on offer. What makes it feel gift-worthy: Taste - proper kick, not sweet sludge Looks smart - clean label, glass jar, tidy lid; not fake rustic twine Decent size - not a tiny doll jar for silly money Strong - you use less, lasts longer Clear use - says it’s spot on with cheese or cold meats Simple flavours - onion chutney, apple, English or wholegrain; no weird coffee-mango stuff Yorkshire helps as a tie-breaker, if it actually tastes ace I’ll stick it in a little hamper with crackers and cheddar from Aldi. Job done. If I can’t hit that price, it stays on the shelf.
Craig Hargreaves, 42, Unemployed Adult, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Gut feel? Usually no. I’m not buying a diddy six-quid jar with twine just to look fancy on a shelf. But I will do it sometimes if it actually earns its keep, usually as part of a little hamper. Who and when: Father-in-law at Christmas with crackers and a decent cheddarMate who loves a BBQ for a birthday or housewarmingHost gift if we’re going round for dinner and I can’t be faffed with wineNeighbour thank-you for feeding the cat or taking in parcels What makes it feel gift-worthy: Proper flavour with some bite, not sticky-sweetVersatile - good on cheese, roast, sarnies, leftoversDecent jar size that won’t vanish in two sandwichesSimple ingredients I recognise, clear date, recyclable glassLocal stall where I’ve tasted it, not a fake farm nameTidy packaging that stacks or slips in a hamper
Alison Greaves, 56, Quality Assurance Engineer, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Short answer: rarely. I don’t fling jars at people for the sake of it. If I buy one, it’s because the person will actually use it and I haven’t got time to cook a batch myself. Who: my brother and his lot at Christmas - they demolish a cheese board; a mate in choir who’s a mustard fiend; a neighbour as a small thank you if they’ve watered plants; maybe a Secret Santa if they’re a foodie. Occasion: Christmas hamper, host gift for Sunday lunch, Father’s Day if they love strong mustard. That’s it. Not birthdays - feels like filler. Gift-worthy means: Taste is better than own-brand - I want proper heat or bright fruit, not sugary gloop or vinegar burn. Short, clean ingredients and a clear batch/date. No faff, no fairy tales. Useful flavour - classic with a twist I’ll actually eat with che
Caroline Hargreaves, 60, Registered Nurse, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short answer: no, not as a stand-alone present. I’d usually take a decent bottle or a good cheese. I’d only buy chutney or mustard as a gift if it’s for a cheese-mad person and it slots into a small hamper I’m already doing. Otherwise it feels like padding. Who and when I’d maybe do it: My brother Ian at Christmas, because he does a proper cheese boardNeighbour Maureen as a host gift if we’re doing a Boxing Day buffetNon-drinkers when wine is a non-starter, or a quick thank-you for a meal invite What makes it gift-worthy: Taste first - I can sample it at Kirkgate Market and it’s clearly better than supermarketLocal or seasonal angle I recognise - damson, quince, or Yorkshire rhubarb, not novelty sugar bombsClean label - short ingredients, proper heat or spice, batch/date shown, tamper se
Sophie Hargreaves, 32, Office Manager, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short answer: usually no. I’m not handing over a £7 jar with a curly label just to look fancy. I’ll do it if it suits the person and the price isn’t daft. Who and when I’d actually buy one: My dad or father-in-law for Christmas or Father’s Day, tucked in a proper cheese-and-biscuits hamper. Host gift if we’re round at friends for a roast or cheese night, paired with crackers or a pork pie. Thank-you for a neighbour who’s fed the cat or taken a parcel, again as part of a little bundle. Secret Santa with a tenner limit, if it’s clearly good and not a tiny novelty pot. What makes it gift-worthy: Taste that sounds special and useful, not gimmicky - apple and ale chutney, proper chilli jam, wholegrain mustard with real heat. Local and honest - made in Yorkshire, plain label, no waffle about s
Kelly Atkinson, 47, Customer Success Manager, Bradford, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Not usually. I don’t gift condiments unless I know the person will actually eat it. If I do, it’s for Mum and Dad at Christmas with a bit of cheddar, or my mate Claire who loves a cheese board, or as a small thank-you if someone cat-sits Marmalade. I’ll buy from a local market in Saltaire where I can taste it. Supermarket shelf with twine and a tale? That’ll not wash. Budget wise, I’m fine at about £4-ish for a decent jar. £7-8 for brown mush in a fancy label can jog on. What makes it feel gift-worthy: Big flavour you can smell and taste. Proper kick, not syrupy. Short, straight ingredients and a clear weight. No faff. Good texture and visible fruit or seed, not gloop. Local maker I can point to, or a small batch sticker. Real, not pretend rustic. Solid glass jar and a tidy label. No fake
Helen Carter-Sharma, 56, Carpenter, Manchester, Greater Manchester, United Kingdom:
Short answer - rarely. I’m not buying a £6 jar just to look fancy on someone’s shelf, that’s daft, innit. I’d sooner take a small homemade chutney with a loaf from the market, or a box of samosas if it’s a proper thank-you. If I do buy one, it’s for someone who actually lives for it - my mate Mo with her cheese boards, or my husband’s uncle who loves a punchy mustard with pakoras. Occasions would be Diwali hampers, a neighbour thank-you, or a small Secret Santa at the workshop. Never as a big main gift - more a topper alongside something fresh. What makes a condiment feel gift-worthy to me: Taste first - real spice on the nose, not sweet gloop.Handwritten batch date and the maker on the label - someone I can picture from Levy market or the Curry Mile.Simple ingredients I can read, veggie
Conor Keane, 42, Data Analyst, Kirklees, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short answer: rarely. I’m not gifting a lone jar of chutney or mustard most of the time. Feels a bit stingy unless it’s part of a small food bundle. If I do buy one, it’s tight-targeted. Who and when: - Leah’s dad at Christmas, with a wedge of cheddar and crackers, not just a sad jar - A neighbour who fed the cat - quick thank you, bottle of ale plus a punchy chutney - A mate hosting a BBQ - a hot mustard that actually bites - Posting home to my mam at Christmas - something apple-y that suits leftover ham What makes it gift-worthy: - Immediate flavour wallop when you crack it, not vinegar burn - Clear pairing on the label, like “great with pork pie” so it earns its keep - Short ingredients, fruit or whole seeds up top, not mostly sugar - Decent jar size you’ll finish in a week or two, no
If a condiment brand told you they have been making preserves the same way since 1970, does that heritage story matter to you or is it irrelevant?
When you are buying condiments, what matters most: taste, price, brand familiarity, ingredients, or something else? How do you actually decide in the aisle?
Sophie Hargreaves, 32, Office Manager, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Top line: taste and price together. If it doesn’t taste clearly better for a sane price, no. What matters to me: Taste - proper kick or depth. If it’s bland, it’s out. Price - I watch unit price. I’ll pay a bit more if it’s clearly better, but not daft. Ingredients - short list, real stuff near the top, not sugar-first or gloopy fillers. Pack format - squeeze for ketchup, wide-neck jars for chutney. Lids that don’t crust up. Brand familiarity - matters for ketchup and mayo because Isla notices. For chutney or mustard, not fussed. Size and date - decent shelf life and a jar we’ll actually finish. No tiny “posh” pots. Local - nice if the price is sensible, but not a decider on the weekly shop. How I decide in the aisle: Clock the offers, then compare unit prices with the own-brand I trust.
Daniel Rhodes, 32, Youth Apprentice, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Price first. Every time. Then taste. Brand, nah. Sigh. Ingredients only if it’s loaded with sugar or fake sweetener that tastes odd. My order: Price per 100g - what’s the damage. Own-brand wins most weeks. Over £2.50 for jars like chutney or mustard, it stays there. Taste and thickness - not watery. Needs a proper kick or it’s pointless. Format - squeezy for the kids. Flip cap that shuts. Less mess. Strength - stronger means you use less. Lasts longer, so worth 20-30p more. Deals - yellow sticker or card price can swing it. If a decent brand drops under my usual, I’ll swap. Local - Yorkshire helps as a tie-breaker, but I’m not paying for a label. How I decide in the aisle: Grab the usual own-brand ketchup or mayo. Check the unit price. Scan for an offer that beats it. If not, stick with
How much more would you pay for a jar of chutney or mustard from a small British producer versus a supermarket own-brand? What justifies the premium?
Daniel Rhodes, 32, Youth Apprentice, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Gut feel? 20-30p more tops. Maybe 50p if it’s banging. Over £2.50 a jar, it stays on the shelf. Weekly shop, I grab own brand. Small-batch stuff is a treat, not a habit. What earns the extra: Taste - proper kick, not sweet sludge Thicker - no vinegary water, sticks to a sarnie Stronger - you use less, jar lasts longer Decent bits - real fruit chunks or proper heat Try-before - market stall sample and it wows me Local - Yorkshire made helps, but only if it’s ace Gifts are different. Christmas hamper for mum, I’ll pay up to £3 if it looks smart and tastes mint. For our cupboard at home, nah. Price first, taste second, label last.
Helen Carter-Sharma, 56, Carpenter, Manchester, Greater Manchester, United Kingdom:
Honestly, not much. Maybe 50p more. A quid at a push if it’s spot on. I won’t pay double for a fancy label and a bit of twine - that’s daft. If it’s £4 a jar, I walk on by and buy the plain one or make a pan when onions are cheap. What earns the small premium for me:Taste - real spice you can smell, not just sugar and vinegar.Simple ingredients I can read. No gloopy thickeners.Local and fresh - batch date written by hand, maker at the stall so I can ask and taste.Balance - heat and tang that lifts dal or cheese on toast, not blows your head off.Decent jar I’ll reuse, standard lid, no silly shrink-wrap ribbons. If it’s from a proper small stall on the Curry Mile or a temple fair and it ticks those, I’ll pay that little bit extra. Otherwise, supermarket own-brand every time.
Craig Hargreaves, 42, Unemployed Adult, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Short answer: not much. - Day to day I’ll pay 50p more. Maybe £1 tops if it’s properly cracking - Over £3 for a normal jar? Nah. If it’s six quid for a thimble, jog on What earns the premium: Taste is miles better after I’ve sampled it - proper kick, not sticky-sweetGood texture - chunky fruit or mustard with bite, not gloopyWorks on loads of stuff - cheese toastie, roast, leftover curry, sarniesSimple ingredients I recognise, not padded with sugarDecent jar size that stacks in the cupboardI’ve met the maker at a local market and it isn’t silly money What doesn’t: Twine, wax seals, fake farm names, nice fontsDiddy jars that vanish in two sandwichesA story on the label instead of flavour Only time I stretch is gifts. For home use, mortgage first, mustard second. If you’ve got a pic and a pr
Tunde Adeyemi, 45, Call Center Representative, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
50p more, max on a normal day. If the own-brand is £1.20, I might go £1.70 if it bangs. For mustard, I pay nothing extra - cheap Dijon or wholegrain is fine. For chutney at Christmas with cheese, maybe a quid more, but that’s my ceiling. I’m not paying for a cute label and a sob story. What earns the premium: It tastes proper - strong heat or clear flavour, not just sugar.Thick, not watery. Real chunks or whole seeds.Short list, no weird stuff.I can taste a sample at a market and talk to the maker.Normal jar size, clear date, keeps well in the fridge. Just need to know the total, yeah?
Conor Keane, 42, Data Analyst, Kirklees, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Day to day, not much. I’ll pay maybe 50p to £1 extra over own-brand, tops - nearer 50p for mustard, up to a quid for chutney. If it’s double or triple the price, forget it. I’m not subsidising fancy twine. What earns the premium: Immediate flavour jump - on a cheese toastie or with a pork pie I should notice it straight awayIngredients that aren’t taking the mick - real fruit or whole mustard seeds up top, not mostly sugar and thickenerBalanced heat and spice you can actually smell and taste, not just vinegar burnGood texture - chunky fruit or proper grind, not gloopyGenuinely local - I can point to the maker, ideally tried it at a marketSane price per 100g and a sensible jar size, no gift-box faff For gifts I might stretch further, but for my fridge it’s own-brand unless they properly e
Alison Greaves, 56, Quality Assurance Engineer, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Short answer: not much. Everyday use, I’ll pay 30-50% more tops if it earns it. On mustard, if the own-brand is £1.20, I’ll go to £1.80-£2 if it’s properly punchy. Chutney, if supermarket is £1.80-£2 for 300g, I’ll pay £2.50-£3.50 for 200-250g. Gift jar at Christmas - fine, maybe up to double once - but that’s present budget, not pantry. Worth the premium: I can taste it at the stall, it clearly beats own-brand on flavour; short, clean ingredients; high fruit or proper mustard heat; batch/date on the label; sensible jar size - not a thimble with twine. Not worth it: sugary jam-bomb chutney, gloopy thickeners, watery vinegar burn; vague “artisan” story doing all the heavy lifting; £5 for 150g - can’t be doing with that. If I can’t tell it’s better on a spoon test, it gets zero premium.
Caroline Hargreaves, 60, Registered Nurse, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short answer: not much. For everyday, I’ll pay 50p to £1 over a decent supermarket own-brand. If it’s genuinely a step up and I can taste it at Kirkgate Market, I’ll go to about double at most - so roughly £3.50-£4 for chutney, £3 for mustard. £5-£6 is gift-or-Christmas-board territory only. What earns the premium: Noticeably better flavour - higher fruit content, proper spice, no sugary vinegar hitClean ingredients, whole spices, real mustard heat, no thickenersClear origin and maker details with a batch/date I can seeSensible jar size for one person, decent shelf life, fully recyclable packagingTaste before buying at a market or a solid recommendation from someone I trust What doesn’t: faux-rustic labels, twine, “small batch” fluff, awards I’ve never heard of. If it can’t beat Aldi on
Sophie Hargreaves, 32, Office Manager, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short answer: not much. For the weekly shop I’d pay about 20-30% more, tops. So if own-brand chutney is £1.50, I’ll go to £2 - £2.20 max. Mustard at 85p, I’ll stretch to £1.10 - £1.20. Anything at £3-£4 for a Tuesday sarnie is taking the mick. Otherwise it turns into a £4 jar sulking at the back of the fridge till bin day. What earns the premium: Taste that’s clearly better - richer spice, proper kick, not just sugar and vinegar.Texture - chunky fruit in chutney, mustard with real heat, not baby food.Clean ingredients - short list, fruit first in chutney, no weird syrupy fillers.Genuinely local - made in Yorkshire, not just a crafty label that says small batch.Decent jar size and shelf life - good date, stays good after opening, no faff packaging.Price that isn’t daft - if I can taste it
Deirdre McKenna, 52, Home Health Aide, Belfast, Belfast, United Kingdom:
Honestly? Pennies, not pounds. I’m not paying double for a fancy label and a bit of twine. I’d put the kettle on and think it over, but I still say no. For my own cupboard: up to 50p more. Maybe £1 if I’ve tasted it and it’s lovely. Mustard: near nothing extra. Own-brand is grand. Maybe 20-30p if it’s got a proper kick. Chutney: 50p-£1 more if it’s thick, loads of fruit, not just sharp vinegar. Gifts: I’ll stretch to £1-£2 more if it looks nice in a hamper. That’s me limit. What earns the premium? Taste I can actually tell on cheese or a ham sandwich. Not wishful thinking. Thick, not watery. You use less if it’s strong, so it goes further. Simple list of stuff I know, not loads of sugar and nonsense. I can meet the maker or get a wee sample. Market stall over supermarket shelf all day
Kelly Atkinson, 47, Customer Success Manager, Bradford, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Day to day, I’ll pay about 50p more for mustard and up to £1 more for chutney. If I can taste it at a market and it’s cracking, or it’s a gift, I’ll maybe stretch to £2 more on chutney and £1 on mustard. If it’s double the price for the same size, forget it. I still check the unit price. Twine and a story? That’ll not wash. What earns the premium: Taste that’s clearly better - proper kick, not cloying sweet.Short, honest ingredients. No weird syrups or thickeners.Higher fruit or seed content, good texture.Clear weight and origin. No shrinkflation tricks.Local maker I can point to. That feels worth backing.
What is your honest reaction when you see artisan or handmade on a condiment jar? Does it make you more likely to buy it or does it feel like a marketing trick?
Sophie Hargreaves, 32, Office Manager, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Gut reaction? Eye-roll. Feels like a marketing trick most of the time, like an artisan tax slapped on a jar. If it’s twice the price of the normal stuff at Aldi, I’m not biting just because someone wrote “handmade” in a curly font. I’m only swayed if I can actually taste it at a market, it’s genuinely local, and the price isn’t daft. Otherwise, I’d rather buy the reliable brand and crack on. I’m not paying extra so Isla can smear it on toast and then decide she wants plain butter. As a gift, maybe. For the weekly shop, no.
Daniel Rhodes, 32, Youth Apprentice, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Honest reaction? Eye roll. Artisan on a jar means small pot, big price. Sigh. Mostly feels like a sticker, not better sauce. I ask, what's the damage? Over £2.50, it stays there. If it's on offer and tastes proper, maybe. Most weeks I grab own brand or yellow sticker. From a mate or a school fair, I might try one. Shelf with a rustic label, nah. Marketing trick for me, 8 out of 10.
Kelly Atkinson, 47, Customer Success Manager, Bradford, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Gut reaction? Eye-roll. Feels like a marketing trick to charge a couple of quid extra for the same sauce in a rustic jar. I flip the jar and check the label. If it’s packed with sugar and filler like the cheap stuff, it goes back. I’ll not pay daft money for fancy font. Sometimes I’ll buy if it’s at a local market and I can taste it, and I know who made it. That’s me backing a neighbour, not a brand. But on a supermarket shelf with twine round the lid? Well, that’ll not wash. Taste and unit price decide, not the word “artisan.”
Tunde Adeyemi, 45, Call Center Representative, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
First thought, I roll my eyes. Mostly a trick to stick on two quid extra. If I can taste it at a market and it bangs, maybe I’ll buy one. If it’s on Clubcard price and the jar looks proper, fine. But I’m not paying £4.50 for ketchup just because it says handmade. I flip the jar, check sugar and oil, then I pick the own-brand nine times out of ten. Just need to know the total, yeah?
Craig Hargreaves, 42, Unemployed Adult, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Gut reaction? Little eye roll. Artisan/handmade usually reads as marketing fluff to me and a reason to whack a couple extra quid on the sticker. So no, it doesn’t make me more likely to buy. I’ll bite if it’s from a local stall where I’ve had a taste and chatted to the person, or if the price is near the normal stuff. Otherwise I’m happy with supermarket own-brand and I’m not paying for twine and a nice font. If I’ve tasted it - maybeIf it’s local and not silly money - maybeIf it’s in a fancy jar for 6 quid - jog on Had a cracking chilli jam from a bloke at the Kings Heath market once, but that was because it was actually good, not because the label said handmade. If you’ve got a pic of the jar, stick it here and I’ll give you a straight yea or nay. Cheers.
Alison Greaves, 56, Quality Assurance Engineer, Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom:
Gut reaction: marketing trick. Nine times out of ten it means a tiny jar, big price, rustic label doing all the work. On a supermarket shelf, I ignore it and check unit price and ingredients. If it’s stuffed with sugar or thickeners, can’t be doing with that. I batch-cook chutney at home when fruit’s going soft, so “handmade” doesn’t impress me on its own. At the Kings Heath market, if I can taste it and talk to the person who made it, fair play - different story, but that’s about proof, not the word on the sticker. I’ll buy: local stall, short ingredient list, clear batch/date, I can taste it. I’ll skip: faux-rustic label, vague story, premium price with nothing to back it up.
Conor Keane, 42, Data Analyst, Kirklees, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Honestly? Artisan or handmade on a condiment jar makes me suspicious. Nine times out of ten it’s just a fancy label, a smaller jar, and a daft price. I’m not paying extra for twine and a faux-handwritten font. I’ll bite only if it actually tastes better and the basics check out: Price per 100g isn’t taking the mickFirst three ingredients aren’t just sugar and cheap fillerMade by a real local outfit I can point toI can taste it at a market and it’s noticeably better In the supermarket, buzzwords don’t sway me at all - I’ll grab the solid own-brand and be grand. So default is no, prove me wrong with proper flavour and a sane price.
Caroline Hargreaves, 60, Registered Nurse, Leeds, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom:
Short answer: No. I usually roll my eyes. Artisan or handmade reads like a price hike. I’m not more likely to buy it - if anything I get cautious. If I can taste it at Kirkgate Market and it’s clearly from a proper small producer, I’ll consider it. What actually sways me: Clear origin I recognise, not vague “small batch” fluffShort, sensible ingredients and a noticeably better flavourReal maker details and batch/date, not faux-rustic labelsPrice that matches contents - I won’t pay £6 for sugar in a pretty jar Otherwise it’s just marketing in a fancy pot. I’ll pay for flavour, not twine.
Helen Carter-Sharma, 56, Carpenter, Manchester, Greater Manchester, United Kingdom:
Honestly, I roll my eyes nine times out of ten when I see artisan or handmade on a condiment jar. In the big shops it feels like a sticker to bump the price for the same gloopy stuff - it's daft, innit. If I'm at the market or a temple fair and there's a real person who can tell me what's in it, and the label looks like someone actually wrote the date, then I might pay extra. I trust the aunties on the Curry Mile far more than a fancy font and a bit of string round the lid. Money's tight so I usually buy the plain jars that taste proper or I make a small batch at home when onions are cheap. So yes - usually a marketing trick for me, unless I can see the maker and taste it there and then.
Deirdre McKenna, 52, Home Health Aide, Belfast, Belfast, United Kingdom:
Honestly? I roll my eyes. Mostly a marketing trick, if you ask me. It usually means a dear price and a bit of twine on the lid. I’m watching the pennies, so I’m not paying extra for a story on a label. What if it’s the same sauce in a fancier jar and I’ve wasted my money... that does my head in. I’ll make an exception if I can see who made it and taste it - like a wee stall at St George’s Market. That feels real, and it’s nice for a gift. For day to day, I just want it to taste right and be decent value. No fuss. Supermarket shelf with “artisan” on it: nope, I skip it.Local maker I can chat to and sample: maybe, as a treat.Christmas or a hamper: grand, looks nice for gifting.